|Books : History : English
Formatted, spell-checked and OCR artefacts removed from existing ebooks.
Nestor Makhno in the Russian Civil War by Michael Malet (1982)
The Anarchism of Nestor Makhno, 1918-1921 by Michael Palij (1976)
STARTING IN the 1970s, a new consensus emerged among scholars of the Russian Revolution. Instead of seeing the rise of Stalinism as the predetermined outcome of Leninism or workers’ power, “revisionist” historians looked instead to the devastating effects of civil war and international isolation. They discovered that the early years of the workers’ state were far more complicated and rich than the standard right-wing inevitable-march-to-totalitarianism version. In its broad outlines, their work confirmed that material conditions, rather than Bolshevik original sin, transformed a mass, popular revolution into its opposite, Stalinism.
"Michael Malet and Michael Palij have both written good monographs on the history of the Makhno movement, Malet’s book is arguably the best book ever written on the subject. In addition there are various eyewitness accounts and anarchist histories of the movement.
Michael Palij, one of the few American historians to write a book on the Makhnovshchina, said, “The history of the Makhno movement, despite its significance to the history of the Ukrainian Revolution and the Russian Civil War, has generally been neglected.”
The Makhnovshchina was not perfect. [...] allying with the Bolsheviks was a big mistake and there were other flaws. But it was vastly superior to the totalitarian state implemented by Lenin and Trotsky."
Show Demonoid some love with BitCoin: 1DNoidJdotDyNMm5CxA8XfbgCH8KsCjco3
How to get BitCoins?